A Quick Critical Review: All Signings And Sales We’ve Made Soo Far, Their Positive/Negative Impact On Our Team, and a list of Better Alternatives We Would Have Made!

As the 2024/25 season unfolds, Everton FC’s transfer dealings have been a topic of interest among fans and pundits alike.

The Toffees have made some intriguing signings, but also bid farewell to several key players.

Let’s delve into the details, analyzing each move, their impact on the team, and exploring alternative options that could have been considered.

_Signings: A Fresh Start_

1. _Dwight McNeil: Pace and Skill_

The signing of Dwight McNeil from Burnley has excited fans, who are eager to see the winger’s pace and skill in action.

Although McNeil has shown flashes of brilliance, his end product remains a concern.

2. _James Garner: A Promising Youngster_

The signing of James Garner from Manchester United represents a shrewd move, as the young midfielder has already shown glimpses of his potential.

His creativity and vision will be crucial in unlocking opposition defenses.

_Sales: A Mix of Expected Departures and Surprises_

1. _Richarlison: A Legendary Departure_

The sale of Richarlison to Tottenham Hotspur marks the end of an era, as the Brazilian forward has been a fan favorite.

Although his departure has freed up space for new signings, it’s hard to argue that the Toffees wouldn’t have benefited from his goalscoring ability.

2. _Jordan Pickford: A Surprising Departure_

Jordan Pickford’s move to Tottenham Hotspur came as a surprise, considering his experience and quality between the sticks. The English goalkeeper’s departure has left a void in the Toffees’ defense.

_Alternative Options: What If?_

1. _Hwang Hee-Chan: A Clinical Finisher_

Everton FC could have pursued Hwang Hee-Chan from Wolverhampton Wanderers.

The South Korean striker offers a clinical finishing ability, which could have elevated the Toffees’ attack.

2. _Sander Berge: A Midfield Maestro_

The Toffees could have explored the signing of Sander Berge from Sheffield United. The Norwegian midfielder offers experience, control, and vision, which would have maintained the Toffees’ midfield dominance.

Everton FC’s transfer activity has laid the foundation for a fresh start, but the departure of key players like Richarlison and Jordan Pickford will be felt.

As the season progresses, it’s crucial to monitor the impact of these transfers and adjust accordingly.

The Toffees’ squad has the potential to compete for European spots, but consistency and adaptability will be key.